Showing posts with label college scholarships. Show all posts
Showing posts with label college scholarships. Show all posts

Saturday

Club or School?

If your expectation was to read my thoughts on the battle between high school and club soccer you might be disappointed. I am going to take this to the grass roots level. Where I live, each school district has a youth soccer program for children K - 8th grade.  The club scene is rather muddled - they come and go with the exception of Grand Lake United which has been around seemingly forever.

One of the newer clubs on the local scene is making a big push for youth players to abandon their school oriented soccer programs and play only for their club. I believe this is a huge and monumental mistake. They are asking children to specialize in a single sport at an age when they should be exploring all sports ... and other avenues of interest as well. They need to be kids, not little future college athletes in training.  Trust me, for the overwhelming majority of these kids will never receive a scholarship to play in college.  See here:  College Soccer Scholarships: The Facts

(Hit the jump for the rest of the article)

Wednesday

College Soccer Scholarships: The Facts.

Every so often someone sets a spark off that ignites my frustration and I feel the need to report this article.  Tonight was such a time.  I met the parents of two little boys ages 7 and 9 who seem to think the boys are USMNT material.  They already been have been involved with a local club for 4 years. Have already spent thousdands of dollars. They are now somewhat disenchanted and are looking to move to a more prestigious club in a larger city. The nine year old already has attitude and was damn near uncoachable when we tried to work with him.  This is NOT what youth soccer should be about. These parents (and by extension their sons) are more than likely going to severely disappointed. They need desperately to read an article like this. Don't get me wrong, I honestly hope the kid succeeds and makes one of the USMNT teams. I see zero indication this will happen though. The parents are about to spend enough money on soccer to fully fund their children's college educations  and will have little to show for it when all is said and done.  Such a shame when youth sports are reduced to this. 


This is a reposting of an article originally publish in March 2013 concerning available scholarships for playing soccer in college.  I have not re-researched NCAA regulations since the original writing.  I have received numerous requests to re-post this article. So, here it is... again!

With club tryout season upon us once again I deemed it appropriate to move the article to the front page.  Do not be fooled by clubs who advertise they have helped "x" number of athletes obtain college scholarships for playing soccer. Investigate the claims.  If talking about the prestigious D I programs, you are more than likely to find no one, not a single solitary individual, listed as a scholarship recipient received a full ride. Most will probably have received a fraction of a fully funded scholarship. A quarter to a third and in rare cases 1/2 of a full ride are the norm.  Those who did receive full rides likely did so at NAIA or NJCAA schools.

Bottom line?  If you are looking for money to pay for college, study hard and get good grades.  All the money being spent on playing club soccer?  Invest it in the stock market or even a savings account. The return on investment will be much higher for the overwhelmingly vast majority of you.


NCAA Divison I

At the NCAA Division I level men's soccer is considered to be an equivalency sport. This simply means the number of scholarships that can be offered is determined in part by Title IX. Fewer men's scholarships may be funded due to women's sports not having an equivalency to football.  A school is not mandated to fund it's full allotment of scholarships.

Schools offering Men's Soccer:  199  (this number is in decline in part due to equivalency standards)
Schools offering Women's Soccer: 320  (this number continues to grow in response to equivalency standards)

Mens Soccer Scholarships:  9.9
Women's Soccer Scholarships:  14

Scholarships can be full or partial rides at the Division I level.  With rosters often approaching 30 players the money is distributed very carefully. 


NCAA Divison II

Schools offering Men's Soccer:  179
Schools offering Women's Soccer: 227

Men's scholarships:  9
Women's scholarships:  9.9

Many NCAA Division II schools do not offer football and so there is less discrepancy in scholarship numbers between the sports. Partial scholarships are the norm as coaches can distribute the money to as many players as they wish.


NCAA Division III

Schools offering Men's Soccer:  401
Schools offering Women's Soccer: 424

Scholarships are not offered at NCAA Division III schools.  Student / athletes often rely on academic scholarships and financial aid to assist with costs for school.


NAIA

Schools offering Men's Soccer:  218
Schools offering Women's Soccer: 223

Men's scholarships:  12
Women's scholarships:  12

Partial scholarships are common.  Coaches often reserve monies for student / athletes that do not meet requirements for academic aid.


NJCAA I

Schools offering Men's Soccer:  136
Schools offering Women's Soccer: 118

Men's scholarships:  18
Women's scholarships:  18

Many scholarships awarded at the Junior College level are full rides although partial rides are common as well.






Tuesday

The Financial Costs of Youth Soccer

I suppose it has something to do with club soccer being underway or perhaps it is preparation for high school season? Maybe it is neither or both?  I get inundated with questions about soccer camps this time of year. I understand people ask me because I have worked college camps and conduct camps myself.  I do tire of repeating myself so I am just going to post some general thoughts on it all here.

And, yes, I do realize what I am about to say is akin to shooting myself in the foot.   LOL.

To go to a college skills camp you can expect to spend $500 - $750.00   What you get in exchange is room & board Sunday - Thursday and 7-8 field sessions and maybe 4 "games" played.  LOTs of dirty laundry and very tired kids. They often demonstrate noticeable improvement, especially if this is one of their first camp experiences. Commuting can lessen the cost while still providing the soccer experience.

To go to a college team camp you can expect to pay $200-$250 a player for approximately 3 days of room & board and the right to play 2-3 games a day against other teams. There is usually minimal instruction. 

To have someone come to your school / club or rec program to conduct camps you might be charged anywhere from $20 - $100 per player for 10-15 sessions of instruction. The type of instruction you receive is up to the local organization contracting with the coaches conducting the camp.

Personal Soccer Trainers or small group training can range from $20 / hour to over $100 / hour per individual player. This usually involves technical training and is often specialized - GK training, Striker training, Foot skills, shooting technique and so on.

What are my recommendations?

I struggle with this.  I have worked those college camps. They are the reason I have begun offering camps myself.  We can do it far cheaper and the players stay in their own beds & eat their own food.

Ditto for team camps.

It's the same with which club to play for.  I know people who dish out $1000 - $2500 per season so their child can play for a "prestigious" club.  That often involves a fall, winter and spring season - as much as $7500.00 per year spent of soccer.  And that fee often does not include uniforms, tournament fees, referee fees and other hidden costs.  They like to think it will lead to a college scholarship for their child. Invest the money in a savings account and you will have college paid for - a much sounder and stronger investment in your child than throwing all that money at college coaches, club coaches or personal soccer trainers.

Our local club charges $150.00 for returning players and $220.00 for new players. The $70.00 difference being the purchase of a uniform you get to keep. This is all inclusive. No hidden costs unless a team seeks more than 2 tournaments to play in.

Tournaments fees run between $450 - $750 for a team and you get a minimum of 3 games. 
Think about that for a minute... That is $25-45.00 per player on a club team.  Basically $7.50 - $15 per game or even less if your team gets a 4th game. 

Refer back to those college team camps that charge $200.00 + per player for the right to play games.  That's an entry fee of $3000 - $5000.00 per team for the right to play games at a college facility with minimal actual instruction. That equates to approximately $50.00 per player per game.  Yikes!

"I want the best possible coaching / instruction for my child."  Money is not an obstacle. "My child is going to get a college scholarship."   Um... probably not and almost certainly not a full ride to a D I school.

Read here:
http://cbasoccer.blogspot.com/2013/03/college-soccer-scholarships-facts.html

So, it comes down to spending your money wisely AND the type of experience you wish your child to have. I cannot make that decision for you.

What we do as a family is seek to get the most bang for our buck.  Our youngest son played for a local club. We paid $350 instead of standard $150.00 because his team played in two leagues and more than the allotted two tournaments.  Over 30 games total.  A little more than $10 / game and that is not including all the practices and "friendlies" or scrimmages.  Great value for the money spent. And Lance has received a partial college scholarship to supplement his academic scholarships

We sent Lance to a  high school team camp at a college last summer and felt like we were being financially raped. Over $200.00 for 3 days of playing games.  We felt compelled to do it because this is what the high school coach has dictated. I would much rather bring a camp to the high school fields, pay considerably less money and have the kids receive 20 - 30 hours of instruction than pay for the "privilege" of playing games on a college campus.

In fact, the high school team conducted a soccer camp of its own for youth in the area. I can almost guarantee you the high school kids benefitted more from instructing the youth players in proper technique than they will from playing multiple games a day on a college campus.  They were fresher, more alert and had much more fun. The middle school campers who attended the high school camp received instruction at a reasonable cost.  The camp generated some excitement within the local soccer community for the high school team. It exposed the middle school youth to the proud tradition of the high school program.

FUN.

Lost among the dollar signs and fatigue from playing too much soccer in a short period of time is the most basic and best reason for playing soccer in the first place = to have fun.

I am constantly reminded of the great Johan Cruyff's quote: "Soccer is simple, but nothing is more difficult than playing simple soccer."   We as adults, as parents, complicate what is a simple game by over spending on it.  Keep it as simple as possible and your pocketbook now and at the time your child goes off to college will appreciate it.  When it comes to soccer camps, instructions and club experiences, more (money) is does not necessarily mean better and is in fact quite often counter productive if the long term goal is paying for college.

Thursday

Is Money an Obstacle to Development?

Recent writings have included topics like Winning vs Development and Thoughts on the current Development Model.  I suppose one might think there has been an overly critical lean to these writings, but that is not the intent. The purpose of these writings is to draw attention to some of the obstacles we must overcome if we are to produce better players than the current model allows for.  In response to these articles one of our readers suggested money is another obstacle that needs to be overcome.  I agree.

Children begin playing soccer in recreational leagues where a nominal fee covers a uniform, field maintenance and perhaps referees.  Soccer blue bloods tend to look down their noses at these recreational leagues, but these leagues are where the seeds of passion for the sport are planted and begin to sprout. Young children playing with and against their friends and neighbors. Yes, the quality of coaching can be found to be lacking and the level of play can be rudimentary.  However, something good is happening in recreational leagues or the sport would have died out long ago.

The next rung on the developmental ladder is to join a local club team.  If you live in a big city there will be many options to choose from. Each club might well field multiple teams for both boys and girls in each age group. If you live in a rural area there is more likely one club with one team in each age group. If your community is really small the teams might be co-ed. Regardless of how the club is constituted the fees for participation will increase over play at the recreational level. Costs to be covered begin with uniforms, field maintenance and referees but expand to include some of or all of the following: League fees, tounament fees, equipment fees, coaches pay, trainer's fee and other costs.  Sometimes the bigger the club or the more well known the club is, the more costly it is to participate "for" the club.

Suddenly a $25 - $50.00 fee for playing recreationally has exploded to $200 - $1000.00+  per season to play.  At the club soccer level the calendar year runs from August 1 through July 31st. Within that calendar year is a fall league season, winter indoor season(s) and spring league seasons.  Some teams will play in multiple leagues in a season. I know people who pay in excess of  $5,000 a year to a club for the right for their child to play soccer.  Many times the fees a club charges do not include the costs of uniforms, warmups, equipment bags, tournament fees.  When "hidden costs" such as travel, food and lodging at tournaments are factored in money certainly can become an obstacle to developing players.

The steps beyond club soccer are academies, Olympic Development Programs, State and Regional teams. Each of these come with additional expenses especially associated with travel.  When I mention travel it is important to consider the time commitment involved in transporting players to and from practices / training and competitions. If you live in a rural area and must travel to a city travel time can be 15-20 hours a week and this does not account for actual practice time.  In a sense, it's like having a second job and in some cases having a third job because a second job is required to pay for the experience.

I coach in a small rural club. I know from experience the exhausting nature of traveling 1.5 hours one way multiple times a week so my son could train with a MRL team. We were fortunate enough to be able to afford that experience. Not everyone is so fortunate. Our small club charges between $150 - $220.00/ season to particate. Our coaches do not get paid. We operate on a shoe string budget and still there are kids who cannot afford to play. We are the least expensive option available and still provide a quality experience thanks to the dedication of the volunteer coaches. I have paid for under privileged athletes to participate in addition to my own sons.  Our club leaders(s) refused to scholarship any athletes despite my repeated pleas to do so for the sake of the kids.

By now, thoughts of kids slipping through the cracks due to a lack of financial resources to play soccer should be running through your head. As a high school coach I see kids that have slipped through the cracks  all the time. They come to us in increasing numbers each fall. Players with a passion for the game who have worked largely on their own to be able to play for their high school team. Their skills are raw and underdeveloped for the most part. Many times they are really good athletes. I'm left to wonder how good they might have been if they had learned to play in a competitive team environment?

High school soccer is considered second rate by many club officials. Instead of working with the high schools many clubs set themselves up in direct competition with high schools. The academy and so-called eltite clubs are beginning to demand a 10 month committment from players that includes an exclusion from playing high school soccer. And people are buying into this nonsense.

Most high school soccer remains "free" to play. That is, your tax dollars allocated to the schools support the athletic programs as well as the classroom. There are increasing numbers of high schools charging a "participation fee" for extra-curricular activities. These can range from $25 - $250 per school year but generally cover all extra-curricular activities for a year. I know there are kids who shop for school districts where they will not have to pay to play or where there is help to pay for those costs.

It seems to me money is an ever increasing obstacle to development in soccer. When parents weigh the cost for development agains the returns it becomes obivious the quality of the general experience has to justify the monies being spent. Very few student / athletes are awarded money for college and even fewer ever make it professionally.  If neither education nor profession are returns on investment, all that is left is the experience itself, correct?



Tuesday

How many players have you sent on to college?

How many players have you sent on to college?

Last week I was contacted by a coach inquiring about having me work with her team. We were not 3 minutes into the conversation when she asked how many players I had "put into college".

Yeah, there was a pregnant pause there as I thought over how to answer that one.

After quickly collecting my thoughts I replied "none."

Now, there have been quite a few players from my teams, clinics and camps who have gone on to play in college but I take no credit for their success. The players put in the work and reaped the reward. 

That answer wasn't good enough for her and after a few more attempts to have me name players and colleges she exasperatedly asked, "Then what is the purpose of your camps and teams?"

I gave the standard reply to the questions about the club teams I coach - We founded the club to prepare area players to play for their high school teams.

As far as my camps are concerned - After working college camps and ODP, I knew I could offer a similar experience at far less cost and the kids could sleep in their own beds and eat home cooking.

Needless to say, I do not expect to hear back from her. It sounded to me like she was looking for a short cut, a magic bean, that could transform a player into a college recruit. Don't get me wrong, good coaching is always an advantage, but it is not the difference maker and anyone telling you it is, is likely trying to line his /her pockets with your hard earned cash.

No, the difference maker is the player.

More precisely it is the player who always has a ball at his feet.  The player who is constantly working on his game.  The player who goes to sleep thinking about soccer and wearing a new pair of cleats to break them in, the player who awakes from a dream about soccer and whose first thought each morning is about how quickly he can have a ball at his feet.



Monday

Sometimes I feel like I am beating a dead horse.

Here is another good article about youth sports. It's a short read and well worth the time.

http://www.boston.com/lifestyle/health/mdmama/2013/05/parents_lets_keep_some_perspective_about_youth_sports.html



At my son's soccer game the other day, a parent kept yelling very loudly at one of the players on the other team, giving various directions as to what the player should and shouldn't do. When I say "very loudly", I mean so loud--and harsh--that it startled me each time.

The kids were first graders.
 
The mother of one of my son's teammates (who was wincing along with me) told me how at her daughter's soccer game earlier that day, the coach of the other team was berating the players, telling them what a terrible job they were doing and calling them names.
 
Those kids were sixth graders.
 
Really?
 
Now, I get that these are extremes. But with five kids, I've been to a lot of sporting events, and have listened to a lot of parents and coaches pushing--in good ways and bad ways--kids to achieve. And while achievement is generally a worthy goal, I'm not sure it's the best goal for youth sports.
 
Often, when I talk to other parents, I hear stuff about hoping for athletic scholarships. I've got two kids in college now, and so know first-hand how outrageously expensive it is and how every little bit helps. But only about 2 percent of high school athletes get athletic scholarships to college--and very few of them are full rides. The chances of "going pro" are even smaller: about 0.03 percent for basketball, 0.08 percent for football, for example. Basically, unless your kid is extremely gifted and extremely lucky, he's not getting any money out of sports.
 
Here's what your kid can get out of youth sports:
  • Exercise. With a third of US kids overweight or obese, we need to get more kids moving. Not only does exercise help kids now, it builds healthy habits for a lifetime.
  • Friendships. Sports can be a great way to build relationships and social skills.
  • Positive self-image. Feeling strong and learning skills can make a kid feel really good about herself.
  • Involvement in positive activities. Sports are a way better way to spend your time than video games or hanging out on the streets; for many kids, sports are what keep them on a good life path.
  • Time management skills. Athletes, especially high school athletes, need to learn to get homework and other things done around practice.
  • Fun! With the right approach and attitude from the athlete and the coach, sports can be a lot of fun.
They are, however, not fun when you are being yelled at--or pushed all the time to achieve. Which is probably why the majority of kids drop out of sports before high school--and miss out on all the benefits entirely.
 
So, parents, let's keep some perspective. When you are at the sidelines, let the coach do the coaching--if you are going to yell anything, make it encouragement. If you see coaches treating kids badly, speak up--and find a different team if it continues. Don't push your kids to achieve--we should always try to do our best, but it's not always the point of everything. It's certainly not the point of youth sports.
 
Sometimes it's good enough--better, even--to show up, play the game and have fun.

Tuesday

Is he coachable?

Invariably when a coach contacts me about a player the question of whether he is coachable arises in one form or another and usually very early in the discussion. Coaches want to know a player's capacity for listening to instruction, constructive criticism and suggestions. Will the player be receptive and will he use these focal points as points of emphasis to improve his game and advance to another level of play?  Is the player willing to learn or is he a know-it-all stuck in his ways?

There are lots of skilled athletes looking to play in college.  One of the determining factors in closing the deal between coach and athlete is the players willingness to learn. Is the athlete willing to accept feedback? Will he recognize the constructive criticism, instruction and suggestions are offered to make him a better player?  Athletes who fail to be receptive to coaching are the ones coaches tend to pass on.

On the club and high school level the same holds true. During tryouts coaches will often give "pointers' to the group and then watch carefully to see which players work to address these suggestions. I do this frequently with teams I coach. If there is a battle for a starting position or role on the team, which athlete do you think is more likely to win out?

How do you take constructive criticism, instruction and suggestions?

Do you react or do you respond?

Reacting typically involves competitive responses.  A coach will offer insight, instruction or suggestions and the athlete will be argumentative or dismissive either in word or deed. There is a disconnect between coach and athlete. Coaches dealing with this type of athlete will often invoke the word "trust" or lack thereof in association with this type of athlete. A lack of "buy in" will be cited. Coaches choose not to waste their time with this type of athlete.

Responding typically involves reflective, open minded thinking on the part of the athlete. There is a willingness to step out of established comfort zones with an acknowledged prospect of broadening their game. There exists an eagerness to learn as opposed to a stubborness to new ideas. Responding often involves question and answer discourse between coach and player that serves to build a relationship whose foundation is trust.  When a coach knows the athlete buys into the program he is more apt to be willing to invest as much time as necessary to help the athlete develop.

Coaches, the good ones anyways, are hyper-sensitive to "coach-ability".  The best coaches are  themselves coachable. These are the men and women that are students of the game. They are always in search of more knowledge.... and by extension they expect the athletes they coach to be receptive and eager learners as well. Technical and tactical knowledge are musts but the ability to build reltionships that foster receptiveness to learning from constructive criticism, instruction and suggestions is also a focal point of a coaches continuing education.  In the end though a coach wants to see the same level of committment to the relationship from the player as he himself puts into the relationship. If a player is not receptive and responsive, coaches typical dismisss them and find others who are. It comes down to decision-making on the athletes part. It's an athlete's choice to be coachable.

Thursday

The Starting Point for a New Development Model?

For those of you in the United States, have you ever seen a soccer scout?

Think about it for a minute.

Baseball scouts taking in a high school game?  Yes.

College football coaches coming to your local high school? Yes.

Basketball coaches coming to your school or watching AAU games? Yes.

A recent article about Boston Celtics assistant GM  Ryan McDonough details his contributions to their scouting department. Of note is his tracking 750 - 1000 professional, college and high school plaers at a time. The articles provides an example of a recent scouting trip where he takes in 4 games in 4 different cities in 4 days. Such are the lengths the Celtics go to in search of players.

In almost 15 years, I have seen exactly one college soccer coach at a high school match evaluating talent. This despite some excellent high school programs producing student ahletes who go on to play in college. I have never seen a "professiona" scout at a high school soccer match.  In nearly 20 years I have never seen a college or professional soccer coach evaluating talent at a club team league game. College coaches can be seen at a handful of major tournaments and at the popular showcase events where they invariably track the players on "elite" club teams.

For the most part, soccer clubs expect you to come to them. There is "poaching" of players from other clubs with each new tryout season, but even those players are usually identified by a team having played against them the prior year. I actively scouted nearly 100 players last fall for a spring roster of 18-20. I felt compelled to if I wanted to assemble a quality team.  I've been wondering for months why clubs, colleges and US Soccer does not scour the ranks of youth soccer to identify young players?

Let's pick on ODP for a minute.  If you coach or play club soccer ODP officials will use your contact information for a mass emailing announcing the ODP tryout and training schedules.  I do not know of anyone who has ever received a personal invitation to the initial process. They expect you to come to them. I have taken part in this process and it is ridiculous. Anyone from the lowest level of recreational play to eventual state or even national team players show up in droves. 

If we want to change the development model I feel strongly the place to start is with a scouting department in each "state."  We need scouts on the local level indentifying taent and reporting to a state level scout who comes out to the local pitches and scouts individuals more in depth. That state levl scouting director should be tracking a thousand student athletes each year in order to identify players with the potential to play on state and national teams. No stone should remain unturned in pursuit of talented players.

It's simply time for the tail (clubs) to stop wagging the dog.  Instead of parents paying for their children to play club soccer, clubs should be scouting / identifying players and then funding their development.  This is how it is done in baseball (college and minor leagues), in basketball  (college, D-League, overseas) and football (college). Youthful players are scouted, recruited and provided an education, room and board or are paid while they develop their game.  In soccer we expect people to pay to be developed. That's not working out real well for us, is it?