Showing posts with label coaching resources. Show all posts
Showing posts with label coaching resources. Show all posts

Monday

Communication and Relationships - The Art and Science of Coaching

Back in my college days I took a couple of courses on coaching.  The "professors" were basketball and football coaches.  Both courses were largely anecdotal with a fair smattering of logistical considerations thrown in. I'm not sure how much I actually learned about coaching, but they were fun classes.

Soccer is one sport that actually promotes coaching education through the USSF and NSCAA as well as a few smaller organizations.  Even so, many people in our area are given a whistle, clipboard and roster of players then declared a coach as is the standard in most sports.

Even within the soccer family the quality of education provided and required is a bit murky.  The USSF largely tests ones knowledge to an extent if you do not know what you are doing the only real benefit to be gained from some of their courses is the re-verse engineering of them so that you might pass on your second try.  The NSCAA does a much better job of teaching the art and science of coaching but in no way, shape or form provides an extensively inclusive education.

While the two organizations are friendly rivals competing for your dollars they are also complimentary in the sense many coaches take the NSCAA courses as preparatory work for the USSF courses.  For all I know, the two organizations may be in cahoots with one another?

The fact remains, if you wish to coach at the upper levels of the game - college or professional - one must have passed the USSF "A" licensure course or a foreign equivalent.  There is not another major sport that requires such a license to coach.  In sports like baseball, football, basketball and hockey the "license" a coach obtains is from experience and success.  If your teams are successful, your experience as their coach is deemed proof of your ability to coach.

That leaves many people to stumble upon the art and sciences of coaching. Playing experience becomes a factor, but the most important aspect of learning to coach will be those you learn the game from - your coaching mentors.  When it comes to soccer, for me this is Graham Ramsay and Ken White.  I learned the "do's" of coaching from these gentlemen.  I have learned what not to do from the school of hard knocks - my own mistakes and those of people who have coached me or my sons. 

Becoming a student of the game is something I have written often about, but as I type today I think a better description of that process would to become a student of coaching and a student of the game. Even in this context the single most important thing to recognize is the relationship aspect of coaching.  Building the coach / player relationship is the very foundation of coaching. 

Over the years I have certainly learned more about soccer.  I know far more about each component of the game - technique, tactics, physical and psychological - then I ever dreamed existed when I started out as coach of an undefeated U6 team 20+ years ago.  I've learned even more about relationships - how to build and maintain them - and this has been the enduring life lesson soccer has taught me. 

It's not all been positive though.  I recently wrote a letter of recommendation for a coaching candidate and closed it by offering the highest form of endorsement I have - I would not only allow, but welcome the opportunity for my children to play for the candidate.  There are very few people who receive that endorsement from me.  For example, my wife and I allowed our sons to play for the local high school coaches even though we did not welcome their opportunity to do so with open arms.  We recognized the coaches as trustworthy men even if we did not always appreciate or respect their coaching methodology. More specifically we did not appreciate the lack of quality in the coach / player relationships.

Going through the college selection and recruiting process with your youngest son the considerations are finding a school Lance likes that offers the degree he seeks and has a coaching staff he connects with.  Trust me, that is a tall order.  Lots of good schools. Many offer the course of study he wants to pursue. Several have soccer programs with coaches who are expressing interest. Do any of them meet his expectations in all three areas?

As I contemplate this, I cannot help but wonder how many parents approach youth soccer or youth sports in general in this manner?  I know there were youth coaches I did not want anywhere near my sons.  We either avoided them or in the one instance with Lance we pulled him out of the program to avoid his exposure to her "coaching."

I know there are some who do not wish to play for me.  I understand that.  With me, I do not play favorites. You might believe you are the best player around, but if you expect special considerations you might as well go elsewhere.   Not happening in my program.   A classic example of this was a player named Kelly.  Kelly and her parents had the perception she was the best player the program had ever produced and somehow based this and her value / worth as a player on Kelly scoring a great preponderance of the teams goals.  When I introduced a system of play with balanced scoring, they thought Kelly's soccer playing world had come to an end even as the program enjoyed its most successful seasons ever on the field.  I understood this even as I never understood this.

We are speaking to the "art" of coaching in the sense that beauty is in the eye of the beholder.  Kelly and her parents never really challenged the science behind my coaching.  They readily admitted that I knew the game as well as anyone they had encountered, they just didn't appreciate how I applied that  knowledge when it came to Kelly.  Their contention was I held Kelly back even as the team was wildly successful.  The disconnect was on a relationship level. 

The art and science of coaching are tied together by the relationship bond between coach and players.  Sometimes I feel salesmanship is one of the most important aspects of coaching. Being able to sell players (and their families) on the programs goals and ideals is crucial to achieving "buy-in" which in turn is the single most important determining factor in a teams success.  Of course, we are talking about communication.  The players, the team must be receptive to what the coach is selling and effective communication is the cornerstone for success in this area.

If a team does not buy into the coach's program -  his formation and system of play, his expectations for standard of conduct -  it's going to be a long season marked by underachievement and discontent... even if the team happens to be winning.  A team that buys-in tends to be a happy team even when the on-field results are not as good as they might be.  The perception that they are improving each time they step on the field, that the process is working, can cover for a lot of disappointment and frustration. Again, we address not only the art and science of coaching but the importance of building relationships.  Coach / player relationships.  Effective communication. 

What about player / player relationships?  Team Chemistry.  Team Bonding.  This too is very important and within the purview of the coach.  It's not about fostering an environment in which everyone loves one another. Its all about building trust and respect within the team setting.  It's all about individuals being able to effectively communicate with one another and trust what is being communicated to each other.

Relationships. 

Trust is the glue of life, the most essential ingredient in effective communication. Trust is the foundational principle that holds all relationships together.  The beauty of art will always be in the eyes of the beholder and the science of the game will always hold certain truths therefore the difference maker from a coaching perspective is found in relationships.  Coach / player and player / player relationships.  Effective Communication.  Trust and Respect.



Friday

The Circle of Soccer Life

I woke up this morning with a distant memory of coaching soccer on my mind. I was coaching a team of U8's and had just introduced a foot skill to the group.  Delaney was working hard at learning it. I could see the concentration on her face and in her eyes as she set about attempting the move.  She completely botched it, but picked up her ball and ran over to me extremely excited with what she had accomplished!  I applauded her effort, patted her on the shoulder and gave her a big smile. Delaney went back to working on the move and it got a little better with each attempt. She eventually became pretty good at executing the skill.

Learning to coach is a lot like learning a new foot skill. The beginning effort needs to be applauded to encourage continued improvement.  As an observer, sometimes no matter how poor the result, you just have to smile in the moment and be content things will improve with experience and continued practice.

In that regard, the evolution of a coach is a bit like referring to a doctor "practicing" medicine.  We really don't want a doctor to practice at healing us, we want the actual real healing!  LOL. 

Do you want to be seen by Dr. Stone or Dr. Hogue?

In the 1991 classic Doc Hollywood newly licensed Dr. Benjamin Stone misdiagnoses a case of mitral valve regurgitation leading to late cyanosis in a young boy. The town's long-time doctor, Aurelius Hogue, order's Dr. Stone to give the boy a Coke. Shock full of confidence and self-importance, Dr. Stone dismisses Dr. Hogue's recommendation and calls for a life-flight helicopter to transport the boy to a large city hospital where he can be seen by a heart specialist for emergency surgery. Dr. Hogue arrives just in time to explain that the boy had gotten into his father's chewing tobacco again and the carbonic acid in the Coke would relieve the boy's stomach ache.  "That'll be 25 cents." LOL

There is no substitute for experience. And as Dr. Stone discovered experience is often gained through making mistakes. Sometimes the innocent are caught in the learning from mistakes another makes on the road to obtaining experience. When that happens, it's nice to have a Dr. Hogue around to keep things on course and mitigate the potential consequences.


Saturday

Theoretical Learning vs Practical Exerience

Let me begin by acknowledging that I am an avid reader. I also have a stated goal to learn something new every day. Hopefully several somethings new every day.  In regards to soccer I have a collection of over 500 books and videos. A library of potential soccer knowledge, if you will. Some are quite good and well worn. Others are complete rubbish and used but once.  Most fall somewhere in between. Today, I wish to focus on one book whose title and author I will refuse to name.

Got your attention?

I was an acquaintance of the author and agreed to review the book.  I found it simplistic and informative.  The whole premise was not to present new material, but to present material in a new way. New names were given to old activities. The book was illustrated in the manner of a children's book complete with caricatures helping to depict the new names given to activities. The pulse of the book was to not focus on proper technique but simply to find a way to "git r done."  A Larry the Cable guy approach to coaching soccer if you will.

In retrospect, it would seem the author was attempting to meld theoretical learning with his practical experiences and in doing so share his vision for coaching soccer. An admirable yet daunting task that he chose to present in as simplistic a manner as possible. Almost a noble undertaking in some ways.

For the most part the book was innovative only in presentation except for a section on defending - The Triangle Three. The premise was not bad, but the books instructions for how tactical aspects of soccer should be executed left many to question the author's sanity and those who sought practical experience with the Triangle Three reported back disastrous results. What was written in the book, simply was not practically applicable.  The author was most offended and the succeeding arguments damn near destroyed an on-line forum of soccer coaches until the sites administrator banned the author from further participation.

The point I seek to make is this - theoretical learning or book knowledge has limited value until practical experience is gained in the subject matter. It can be more beneficial to gain practical experience and then read material to gain a clearer understanding of the theory.

I saw the triangle three in action this fall. It was shredded by a team of average ability. I knew the coach employing it had read the book in reference here. The theory is sound but the instructions to apply it in a practical sense are ridiculously naive.

I have also seen a coach carrying a different book with him this fall. A book about a system of play he is introducing to a team. He's using the book, the theoretical learning he is gaining, as a step by step means to introduce and play the new system. Results have been less than desired because the coach lacks practical experience in teaching the system of play. I have three years of practical experience in the system and can pinpoint the areas where this coach is struggling in applying his book or theoretical knowledge.

My path to the system of play was a product of need. Three years ago my club team started out in a 4-4-2 formation but it quickly became apparent we did not have the correct combination of center midfielders to control the game from the 4-4-2. Really good opposing center midfielders gave us problems on both sides of the ball.  My on-the-fly solution was to withdraw a forward and play a 4-5-1 formation with an extra center midfielder.

Drastic change.

The 4-5-1 is really not a variation of the 4-4-2 as much as it is a form of a 4-3-3 formation.  It worked for us from the in-game moment that we begun playing it.  I had absolutely no book or theoretical knowledge to rely on. We all learned on the fly. It wasn't until after that first season of running the new formation that I had time to read books and study DVDs on our new formation.

Today the kids describe what we play as a 4-1-2-1-1-1 or 4-2-3-1 or 4-1-4-1 or 4-1-3-2... entirely dependent on which player you ask. I really do not care what they call it as they play it beautifully. What the books and DVDs helped define were which of the possible applications they espoused worked best for us. The theoretical learning provided us with ideas of how to get the most out of our practical experiences.  What the books and DVDs were not, were step by step how-to manuals for playing the system although some tried to be just this.

I firmly believe soccer is a players game. It is a living breathing thing that must be experienced to the fullest extent possible. We changed alignment and let the kids explore the possibilities to their hearts content. We made spectacular mistakes, but learned quickly from them. We found the path of least resistance as a team. Only then did we begin experimenting with theoretical learning to supplement our practical experiences. The result has been staggeringly successful.

This fall I am watching my son's high school team trying to run the same system. Their coaches have no practical experience with the system and are relying on book or theoretical knowledge to teach the system to the players. Several of our spring players are on this team and they are really struggling in watching their high school coaches make mistakes in the system that they have already experienced  2- 3 years ago. I watch the game film and read the coach's notes on the film.  He is correct in almost everything he points out, but it is also clear he is struggling to fit the practical experience he is gaining to the theoretical knowledge he has obtained. I can say this without reservation because I have the same books and DVDs that I have seen him carrying about these past few months.

I can point to actual parts of the books, specific chapters, paragraphs, sentences that are being misapplied. I see the mistakes in or misunderstandings of theory that play out in gaining practical experience. I have offered the benefit of my own experiences to the coach, but they have fallen on deaf ears. It is indeed difficult to watch this team experience growing pains in the system that I feel could be by-passed.  I do understand the coach wanting to put his stamp on the program, to make it his.

While I was learning how this system works I was not going it alone. The most valuable resource I had was the input players gave me from what they experienced on the field in games. The second most valuable resource I had was film study ... and specifically having coaching friends, peers and mentors evaluate that film with me. I learned from my mentors. Mentoring is the piece missing in this situation. Patience is what is missing from my perspective - my son is a senior on this team and while the coach is gaining practical experience the team is struggling to gain its footing. The season is a third over and they are struggling mightily. Needlessly so from my perspective.  I have complete faith this coaching staff will get it figured out, eventually. I am becoming resigned to the fact it will probably be too late for my son and his senior classmates.